Why Productivity Hacks Can Help (And Hurt) Your Productivity

If you’ve ever tried waking up at 5am, journaling, meditating, taking a freezing shower and squeezing in ‘deep work’ before breakfast - only to feel ready for a nap by 10am - then you’ve probably discovered the strange world of productivity hacks.

They’re everywhere: Pomodoro timers, colour-coded to-do lists, habit trackers, ‘eat the frog’ mornings. The promise is simple: if you do them, you’ll get more done in less time and feel amazing while doing it.

And sometimes, they do help. A well-placed timer can help you focus. Breaking a big task into chunks can make it feel manageable. Research in Cognition (2019) shows that structured routines can reduce procrastination and help with follow-through.

But here’s the catch: the very hacks meant to make us productive can also backfire - adding stress, decision fatigue and ironically, making us less effective.

The Science of Why Hacks Work (Sometimes)

Let’s give hacks their due credit first.

• Pomodoro Technique: Breaking work into 25-minute chunks with rests can align with what psychologists call our ‘ultradian rhythms’ - natural cycles of focus and fatigue (Kleitman, 1963). Short sprints can work better than forcing endless hours.

• “Eat the frog”: Tackling the hardest task first can reduce avoidance behaviours. Studies in Behaviour Research and Therapy (2015) show that avoidance increases stress and makes tasks feel bigger, so facing the tough thing early can ease the mental load.

• Rituals and routines: Morning rituals or end-of-day routines can act as ‘cognitive cues’ that signal it’s time to work, which improves consistency.

So yes - some hacks are backed by science, and for certain people in certain situations, they really do work.

Where Hacks Start to Hurt

But here’s where things go sideways: when hacks stop being tools and start being… rules.

• Decision fatigue: Research in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Baumeister, 1998) shows that every choice drains willpower. If your morning involves 12 separate ‘optimal’ steps, you’ve used half your energy before 9am.

• Productivity theatre: A study in Organizational Science (2021) found employees often engage in ‘productivity theatre’ - doing things that look productive (like colour-coding tasks) but don’t improve outcomes. Many hacks encourage this exact trap.

• Internalised failure: When hacks don’t deliver, we don’t blame the system - we blame ourselves. Psychologists call this ‘internalisation of failure’, which can increase shame and reduce motivation (Ryan & Deci, 2000, Self-Determination Theory).

In short: hacks can make us feel worse about ourselves, while not actually helping us get more done.

The Productivity Paradox

The paradox is this: the more time we spend optimising productivity, the less productive we become.

We can get so busy organising the work that we don’t actually do the work.
It’s like rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic - it feels satisfying, but the ship is still sinking.

And research backs it up: a 2022 study in the Journal of Management found that excessive ‘self-regulation strategies’ (aka productivity hacks) correlated with higher stress and lower job satisfaction when overused.

So… Are Productivity Hacks Bad?

Not necessarily. Like most things, it’s about balance.

• Hacks are useful if they reduce friction (like a timer to get started).

• They’re harmful if they add complexity (like 10 apps to track every micro-task).

• They work best when they’re flexible tools, not rigid rules.

As productivity researcher Cal Newport put it: “The goal is not to do more things. The goal is to do the right things with less stress.”

A Low Stress Alternative

Instead of obsessing over hacks, think about energy.

Energy management is the underrated side of productivity. A study in the Journal of Occupational Health Psychology (2016) found that people who rested and recovered well were more productive than those who worked longer hours with hacks.

So maybe the real productivity system isn’t 5am ice baths and Pomodoro marathons. Maybe it’s:

• Sleep

• Focus on fewer things that matter

• Cut the hacks that drain more energy than they save

It’s not glamorous. But it’s effective.

My Final Thought

Productivity hacks aren’t evil. They can help - sometimes a lot. But they’re not magic. And when stacked on top of each other, they can actually sabotage the very productivity they’re supposed to boost.

So the next time you see a 17-step morning routine on TikTok, remember: you don’t need to hack your way to freedom. Sometimes the most productive thing you can do is less - but better.

👉 Want more no-BS, evidence-backed takes on productivity and money? Sign up for my newsletter Too Tired To Think. Practical tips, zero hustle required.